My espresso didn’t survive for five minutes after we broke the inlet. After the through-the-night drive from Ocean Metropolis, New Jersey to Freeport, New York, I’d been relying on that caffeine to maintain the senses sharp for a day of fluke fishing off Lengthy Island’s South Shore. I watched with dread because the metallic mug dismounted from the reducing board onto the deck of Captain Doug Toback’s 35-foot Duffy, the place its contents drained out the scuppers and into an ocean that was simply starting to replicate the predawn gentle.
Fluke, giant fluke, have been the first goal of the journey. Each August, Doug devotes his days to working farther to search out the most important fluke of the season as they start their offshore migration via the New York Bight to the sting of the continental shelf. I didn’t need to be groggy for the prospect at my largest flatfish of the yr, so I welcomed the information that we’d be stopping partway to the fluke grounds for a warmup bonito troll. Nothing clears mind fog just like the sound of a screaming drag.
(Word: On The Water is reader-supported. While you purchase via hyperlinks on our website, we could earn an affiliate fee.)
Atlantic bonito have been in every single place in 2024. They arrived early in New England and settled into midshore tuna grounds off New Jersey and New York in immense numbers. DJ Toback, Doug’s son and first mate on Corazon Fishing Charters, had set solely two of the four-rod trolling unfold after we had the primary knockdown. Over the subsequent couple hours, DJ managed to set all 4 rods solely twice, and even then, it was a matter of minutes earlier than one other bonito interrupted him.
Doug’s bonito unfold seems to be like a miniaturized tuna unfold. He units two small trolling feathers on flat-line clips simply past the propwash. Past them, he fishes two tiny, three-arm spreader bars fitted with 2- to 3-inch soft-plastic squids. The unfold saved bonito with the boat all morning, leaving DJ, Nick Cancelliere, and me in a virtually fixed state of combating fish.
The seas, although calming, had constructed to six ft earlier within the week, courtesy of a stiff south wind. The lumpy situations could have triggered the bonitos’ frenzied feeding, and so they undoubtedly thinned out the would-be fleet working the world. Having the ability to comfortably sail in such “crowd-controlling” forecasts is precisely what led Doug to a Downeast-style boat.
The Corazon had a wealthy fishing historical past earlier than discovering its solution to Doug in September 2020. For years, it labored the waters of Montauk because the Westlake, and whereas it had, as Doug places it, “good karma and an excellent structure,” it wanted some love. Over the subsequent 9 months, Doug and DJ, partnering with Baldwin Harbor Marine changed “principally, every thing” on the 35-foot Duffy.
The upgraded vessel has a spacious, climate-controlled cabin, a big cockpit with loads of fishing room, and a secure, quick experience that permits Doug to fish every thing from stripers simply off the seaside to overnighters within the canyons.
Our bonito ranged from frisky 2-pounders to bigger fish pushing 7 kilos, with the massive ones placing up spirited battles on the sunshine typical deal with. We saved a couple of, launched a bunch, and stayed on the troll into the mid-morning, hoping to tug a bluefin out of the bonito swarm. But, in addition to a stray bluefish and an early false albacore for Nick, we couldn’t get previous the bones.
With the crew correctly warmed up, Toback pushed the boat south for an additional half-hour earlier than pulling again the throttles at one in all his large fluke numbers. In the course of the experience, DJ handed round bowls of rooster rice, an Ecuadorian specialty and the home favourite on the Toback residence. It was instantly obvious why. As we ate our first and second servings, the seas mellowed out, and after lamenting that his spouse makes rooster rice solely when DJ is residence from school, Toback defined his fluke program.
The technique entails quick drifts over small items of construction. As he units up every drift, Doug stays on the wheel, eyes on his fishfinder, working collectively together with his crew, instructing them when to drop. Anybody nonetheless fidgeting with their rig, checking their cellphone, or in any other case day-dreaming dangers dropping their rig too late and having their baits land behind the construction, the place undersized sea bass greedily assault the squid and spearing combos.
Doug’s go-to fluke rig is a high-low rig fitted with floating jigheads, made by M3 Deal with. He provides his crew with the usual spearing and squid pennants, however breaks the mould relating to scented artificials, choosing FishBites over Berkley Gulp. I’ve used my share of FishBites over time, baiting my surf kingfish rigs with the corporate’s imitation bloodworms, however I had by no means fished them for fluke. The bait is made from a scented paste molded round a mesh strip that holds it onto the hook. Within the water, the bait slowly dissolves, sending out a scent path and attracting the fish. They act as an insurance coverage coverage towards bait-stealing species, maintaining anglers from “fishing on credit score” when coming via the candy spot.
We dropped the FishBites E-Z Squid, a white segmented ribbon that Toback reduce into roughly 5-inch lengths. The artificial bait, paired with the colourful skirted hooks and pure baits, made a strong providing to the fluke beneath, with the purpose of attractive the fish that met New York’s strict minimal measurement.
In 2024, New York cut up the fluke season, with the primary half—Could 4 to August 1—carrying a 19-inch measurement restrict, and the second half—historically the trophy fluke season for Lengthy Island’s western South Shore—bumping the minimal measurement to 19.5 inches. In my outdated fishing photograph albums, there are many footage of me grinning extensively whereas holding fluke that, right this moment, wouldn’t even be New York keepers.
Assembly these excessive minimal sizes, together with having a shot at a doormat, is what drives captains like Toback farther offshore for fluke. It’s a typical theme all through the Northeast, with fishermen making related and longer runs to fluke grounds past Block Island or Nantucket, the place fishing water as deep as 100 ft is frequent.
To successfully fish these depths, and maintain the fishing enjoyable, fishermen scale down their braided line to the ultra-thin 20-pound take a look at. This cuts down on water resistance, and subsequently, the quantity of lead wanted to carry backside, which permits anglers to fish lighter, extra enjoyable deal with. On the Corazon, Toback outfits his crews with Daiwa Harrier slow-pitch jigging rods and Daiwa Lexa baitcasting reels that sit comfortably within the palm, making it simple to impart motion to the rig beneath.
Through the years I all the time discovered it exceptional that probably the most ample fluke measurement manages to be simply an inch underneath regardless of the minimal size occurred to be. And so it was aboard the Corazon. We caught 17- and 18-inchers aplenty, and the primary drift yielded a 21-incher that Toback deftly netted for me.
Although I’d been warned, I used to be nonetheless shocked by the shortness of Toback’s drifts. They have been downright surgical as he centered on construction that the substantial fleet of fluke-obsessed New Yorkers simply overlook.
Toback locates these spots by marking a waypoint each time he sees rubble, bait on the underside, or a lump. Even whereas drifting reefs, he makes a brand new waypoint every time a fish is hooked. Over time, this has created areas of clustered waypoints at completely different depths on his chart plotter, and he’s capable of finding the patterns amongst all that knowledge to assist him find the fish. It’s acquainted territory for Toback, whose earlier profession was know-how and knowledge evaluation on Wall Road.
On the smooth backside past the construction, along with the quick sea bass, we caught loads of ling. It had been years since I’d caught multiple or two ling on a visit, so it was nice to see this small member of the cod household arising two or three at a time on a couple of consecutive drifts.
Bug-eyed, slug-shaped, and outfitted with lengthy, tentacle-like fins, ling—formally often called crimson hake—are one of many uglier bottom-dwellers of the New York Bight. Regardless of their homeliness, small measurement, and normal lack of spirit on the top of a line, in a long time previous, ling saved headboats full and crusing proper via the winter months. Their abundance and agency, chicken drew crowds of anglers in search of each a treatment for cabin fever and recent fillets. We added the ling to a cooler and continued our drifts searching for fluke.
It’s a rarity {that a} fishing journey saves one of the best for final. Most frequently, the height comes someday within the center, with a petering out of each the fishing motion and angler enthusiasm till everybody agrees that it’s time to move for the barn. My journey aboard the Corazon adopted that trajectory because the undersized fluke grew to become extra rare, and just one extra keeper hit the deck throughout greater than a dozen drifts.
Toback declared the ultimate drift over one other of his favourite fluke numbers, and as quickly as he declared “Drop them,” three fluke rigs headed for the underside. I used to be staring down the barrel of my rod, prepared a fluke to chunk when, in my peripheral imaginative and prescient, I noticed DJ swing.
The rod bucked wildly and bent to the foregrip, its smooth motion dampening the ferocity of the fluke’s headshakes and maintaining the hook from tearing free. DJ labored the fish to the floor and Doug stabbed out with the online, and the father-son duo closed the deal on the New York Doormat.
Enthusiasm reignited, Toback took the good distance residence, seeing if any of the lobster pot buoys would supply up a mahi so as to add one final splash of coloration to the cooler. We discovered the mahi, however they have been deep and sulking, displaying no real interest in our baits, maybe already having been focused by one other boat heading in from the tuna grounds.
With that, Toback plotted a course towards Jones Inlet. I discovered my long-ago emptied espresso mug and tossed it in my pack earlier than grabbing a seat within the Corazon’s comfy cabin. I thought of closing my eyes and grabbing a fast nap because the boat bounded over the mild swell, however regardless of the early wake-up name and unintentional caffeine quick, I found I used to be awake.
Associated Content material
Trolling Suggestions for Bonito
Seven Suggestions for Hooking Fluke
6 Rigs to Know for Fluke Season
WATCH: Bonito & Fluke Fishing off Freeport, Lengthy Island | S22 E02 – OTW’s Angling Adventures
